A U.S. Navy sailor has spent nine months at sea in the Middle East, fighting a war, setting records for time without a port call, working 12-hour days on a ship the Pentagon insists is fine. ICE's thank-you was to arrest his father near a Publix supermarket in Key West. This is the country the administration is trying to make great again.
Nine Months at Sea, One Traffic Stop on Shore
Joshua Aviles is a sailor aboard the USS Abraham Lincoln, the aircraft carrier that has become the most exhausted ship in modern U.S. Naval history. The Lincoln left San Diego on November 25 and went more than eight months without a port call, breaking the Navy record. It has been deployed to the Middle East as part of the ongoing war with Iran. Joshua has not seen his family in nine months.
On Saturday morning, while Joshua was somewhere in the Middle East doing whatever the Navy needs done on a warship, his father Luis Manuel Aviles was arrested during a traffic stop in Key West, Florida. According to NBC News, Border Patrol agents detained him shortly after 11 a.m. as he was headed to a mechanic. He was near a Publix. He was not carrying a weapon. He was not suspected of a crime. He was going to get his car looked at.
Luis Manuel Aviles is originally from Nicaragua. His stepdaughter Katty Delgado told NBC News he has lived in the United States for roughly 20 years, has a work permit, a Social Security card, and a driver's license. She said she has no knowledge of any arrest history or criminal allegations against him. 'He's doing everything the right way,' she said.
What DHS Has to Say for Itself
The Department of Homeland Security confirmed Sunday that Border Patrol arrested Luis Manuel Aviles during the traffic stop. The agency said he entered the U.S. illegally at an unknown date and location, and that he would remain in ICE custody pending removal proceedings. The specifics of that illegal entry, apparently, are unknown enough that DHS cannot name a date or a place, but certain enough to lock the man up.
When asked by Telemundo whether Luis Manuel Aviles had a work permit, a Social Security number, or pending immigration cases, as his family stated, DHS had a very precise non-answer ready: 'work authorization or a pending application do NOT confer legal status in the United States.' Capitalization theirs. When pressed further, a DHS spokesperson said, 'having a family member in the military is not a free pass to violate our nation's laws.' And then, just to make sure everyone understood the policy: 'Military service by an immediate relative does not automatically grant parole, lawful status, or immunity from immigration enforcement.'
Three separate statements. Not one word of acknowledgment that a sailor who has been at war for nine months just got his father taken away. They stayed completely on message, which is its own kind of answer.
Joshua Aviles, From a Ship in the Middle East, Begging on Facebook
Joshua Aviles found out what happened the way a lot of people find out terrible news now: social media. He has limited internet access on the ship. He posted on Facebook anyway. 'I've been deployed for over nine months, out at sea in the Middle East aboard the USS Abraham Lincoln, fighting for a country that has given me everything,' he wrote Saturday.
'This is heartbreaking for me,' he continued. 'I don't know how I can mentally continue working 12+ hour days knowing that my dad is somewhere, possibly being treated like a criminal.' He said he was doing everything he could to get his father released. He ended with: 'I love you with all my heart. Please stay strong. I'm coming home, Dad.'
The Lincoln, NBC News reports, has officially left the Middle East and is heading back to the West Coast. That journey could take a month or more. Joshua Aviles will be working 12-hour days on a record-breaking deployment for at least another month, knowing his father is in an ICE detention facility, wondering what comes next.
This Is Not an Isolated Case. Not Even Close.
It would be easier to write this off as a bureaucratic mistake, a rogue agent, something that fell through the cracks, if it were happening in isolation. It is not happening in isolation. According to a recent Associated Press investigation, immigration authorities have detained more than 50 parents and spouses of active-duty service members during Trump's second term.
The list of who ICE has gone after in recent months, as NBC News reports, includes children and spouses of service members, a San Diego Padres minor-league catching coordinator, and a grandmother from India who is a schoolteacher with a green card. There are programs, administered through U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services, that can offer military families some protection from deportation. The USCIS website describes them as 'discretionary options' offered on a 'case-by-case basis.' It was not immediately clear whether Luis Manuel Aviles was enrolled in any such program.
What is clear is that the administration knows these arrests are happening, knows the pattern exists, and keeps doing it. Pete Hegseth, the Defense Secretary, has been busy dismissing reports of deteriorating conditions on the Abraham Lincoln as 'completely misrepresented.' He has apparently not found time to weigh in on whether detaining the parents of his sailors is good for morale.
The Ship, the Record, the Context Nobody Should Forget
The USS Abraham Lincoln is not just any aircraft carrier having a hard deployment. The Lincoln left San Diego on November 25 and went more than eight months without stopping at a port, breaking the Navy record. Relatives of sailors on board have described deteriorating conditions and tanking morale. The ship has been at the center of a war with Iran. Its sailors have been cut off from their families for the better part of a year.
Katty Delgado, Joshua's stepsister, said her stepbrother has spent nine months at sea without seeing his family. 'And this is what his father gets,' she told NBC News. There is nothing to add to that sentence. It already contains everything.
The Dingo Take
You are supposed to believe this is about the rule of law. That is what DHS wants you to take away: a principled, consistent enforcement of statutes passed by Congress, applied without fear or favor to anyone who entered this country without authorization, no matter the circumstances. The administration 'does not pick and choose which laws to enforce.' They said that out loud, with a straight face, about the arrest of a man going to a mechanic near a Publix while his son fought a war at sea.
Here is the thing about the 'rule of law' argument: it requires you to ignore that the same administration picks and chooses enforcement constantly, that discretionary protections for military families exist precisely because this situation is not normal, and that ICE has now done this to more than 50 service member families according to the AP. This is not an accident of bureaucratic process. It is a choice, made repeatedly, defended loudly, dressed up in the language of principle so nobody has to say the quiet part out loud.
Joshua Aviles is coming home from nine months of war to a country that arrested his father near a grocery store while he was gone. He wrote that he is fighting for a country that has given him everything. He wrote that on a ship with limited internet access, from the Middle East, begging the public to care. The country he is fighting for sent Border Patrol to grab his dad during a traffic stop and then issued a three-paragraph statement about legal status. If that does not make you furious, check your pulse.
Comments