Donald Trump, locked in a trade war with Canada that just escalated to 50% tariffs, has decided the real problem is the name of a Great Lake. On Thursday, he signed an executive order renaming Lake Ontario 'Lake America,' effective immediately, because apparently the map wasn't sufficiently on brand. Bill Maher has already made his jokes. The rest of us are still processing.
Yes, This Actually Happened
According to the New York Post, Trump signed the executive order from the Oval Office on Thursday, telling reporters with characteristic understatement, 'This is official, effective immediately.' Lake Ontario, which has existed under that name since before the United States was a country, is now apparently Lake America. On paper. By executive fiat. Because a guy in Washington decided he was mad at Canada.
This is the same playbook he ran with the Gulf of Mexico, which Trump renamed the 'Gulf of America' earlier in his second term. Maher, on Friday's episode of HBO's Real Time, noted he now has to 'buy a new globe again,' adding, 'It's like the fifth time it's happened.' Dark comedy, sure. Also just a factually accurate description of the current situation.
The timing is not subtle. Trade talks between the U.S. and Canada collapsed late Friday, and the White House moved forward with 50% tariffs on Canadian goods. So the sequence of events is: rename the lake, blow up the trade talks, slap on the tariffs. A completely normal week of diplomacy.
Maher Goes After Both Sides, As Maher Does
To the surprise of no one who has watched Real Time in the past decade, Maher did not simply dunk on Trump and move on. He turned the camera on liberals, and the joke landed somewhere uncomfortable. 'The liberals are very pissed at this,' Maher said. 'They say you can't just go around changing things to fit your political agenda. Just ask any Latinx birthing person.'
Look, the joke is cheap. It's also not entirely wrong, which is the annoying thing about Bill Maher. The left did spend several years policing terminology with a thoroughness that gave ammunition to anyone who wanted to dismiss the underlying causes as performative. You can hold both things: Trump renaming a Great Lake to own Canada is ridiculous, and the left's occasional tendency to treat language updates as the primary battleground of social progress was a strategic own-goal that people like Maher will be milking until the sun burns out.
Maher is not your friend. He is not the enemy either. He is a man who has made an entire second career out of being the guy who says 'both sides, actually' at dinner parties, and sometimes he is wrong, and sometimes he is annoyingly right, and Friday was a little of both.
The Right Jumps on the Hypocrisy Angle
The New York Post gave significant real estate to NewsBusters, the conservative media watchdog site, to pile on. Managing Editor Curtis Houck told Fox News Digital that liberals' acceptance of terms like 'Latinx' and 'birthing person' destroys any credibility they might have in objecting to Trump's renaming spree. 'The left needs to take a seat before they can say anything about anything being renamed,' Houck said.
NewsBusters Executive Editor Tim Graham went further, pointing out that the left spent years pulling down statues and renaming military bases, and that criticizing Trump's renamings while celebrating those changes requires a level of consistency they haven't earned. 'They just want to be the only people who get to rename things,' Graham told Fox News Digital.
This is the part where we note that NewsBusters is a conservative organization whose entire reason for existing is to attack the media from the right, so their takes should be weighed accordingly. That said, the underlying point, that 'renaming things is fine when we do it and outrageous when you do it' is a bipartisan disease in American politics, and pretending otherwise is just tribalism wearing a press badge.
What Actually Matters Here
The lake rename is a sideshow. The 50% tariffs on Canada are not. Canada is one of the United States' largest trading partners, and a full trade war with the country directly above the border has real consequences for real people on both sides, involving jobs, supply chains, and consumer prices.
Trump has a long history of using symbolic gestures to dominate the news cycle while substantive policy moves go under-examined. Renaming Lake Ontario is exactly this kind of move. It generates outrage, it generates jokes, it gets Maher three minutes of material, and meanwhile the actual trade policy that will affect lumber prices and auto manufacturing and dairy farmers gets buried under the argument about whether it's acceptable to rename a Great Lake.
Canada, for its part, has not announced any plans to rename anything in retaliation, though at this rate it would be understandable if they rechristened Niagara Falls 'Not Your Falls, Buddy.'
The Dingo Take
Renaming Lake Ontario is the geopolitical equivalent of a teenager changing their ex's contact name to 'Do Not Answer' in their phone. It feels powerful. It changes nothing. The lake does not care. Canada does not care. The lake is still there, doing lake things, indifferent to the executive order signed by the man who is also currently threatening its neighboring country with tariffs that could genuinely damage both economies.
The Maher bit is getting more coverage than it deserves, because the media loves nothing more than a 'both sides got owned' moment that lets everyone feel slightly superior without having to commit to anything. Yes, some liberal terminology became detached from the people it was supposed to represent. That is a real criticism. It is also not the same thing as a sitting president renaming international bodies of water during a trade war as a flex. One is a cultural overcorrection. The other is a head of state using geography as a prop for his ego while economic policy collapses in the background.
The scoreboard matters. Trump has now renamed the Gulf of Mexico and one of the Great Lakes by executive order, escalated tariffs on two major allies, and presided over trade talks that keep blowing up. Bill Maher has a joke about a globe. The NewsBusters guys got some quotes in the New York Post. Somewhere, actual trade negotiators are staring at the ceiling at 3 a.m. wondering how to do their jobs when the boss keeps writing new names on the map.
Comments