A 28-year-old woman who worked at an anti-plague laboratory in Siberia has died, and the Russian government says the cause was pneumonia of 'undetermined' origin. The U.S. State Department, meanwhile, says it is monitoring reports of a fatal case of suspected pneumonic plague in the same region. Both of those statements are about the same dead woman. Only one of them includes the word 'plague.'
What We Actually Know, Which Is Not Much
According to NBC News, the woman died Friday, and the World Health Organization says no cause of death has been confirmed. She worked at the Irkutsk Anti-Plague Institute of Siberia and the Far East, located in the Irkutsk region of southeastern Siberia.
A Russian official told reporters she died of pneumonia of 'undetermined' origin and did not connect her death to her job at the institute. Note the phrasing. Not 'pneumonia.' Pneumonia of undetermined origin, delivered with the energy of a man who has been told to say exactly this and nothing else.
The key unknowns, per NBC News, are huge. Nobody outside the room knows whether she had plague at all. If she did, nobody knows whether it was the naturally occurring kind or bacteria being studied in the lab. Nobody knows how fast her illness progressed or what treatment she got.
Nearly 200 People Are Now Under Medical Watch
NBC News reports, citing Russian media, that nearly 200 people who came into contact with the woman are under precautionary medical observation. That is a lot of people to monitor for a routine case of unexplained pneumonia.
Precautionary observation of that scale is what you do when you are worried about something, whatever the official line says. You do not quarantine a couple hundred people because Brenda in accounting had a bad cough.
The State Department, according to NBC, is tracking the situation in coordination with the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. When the U.S. government is publicly saying 'suspected pneumonic plague' while the Russian government is saying 'undetermined pneumonia,' one of them is being more forthcoming. Take a guess.
Plague Is Not Just a Medieval Problem
Quick refresher, courtesy of NBC's reporting. Plague is caused by Yersinia pestis, the bacterium behind the 14th century Black Death. It shows up in three main forms, according to the WHO: bubonic, pneumonic and septicemic.
Bubonic is the most common, microbiologist Lisa Morici of Tulane University School of Medicine told NBC. It spreads through infected fleas or contact with infected rodents and causes painful swollen lymph nodes. It is usually not contagious.
Left untreated, though, it can reach the lungs and become pneumonic plague, which can pass from person to person through respiratory droplets. Septicemic plague is what you get when the bacteria multiply in the blood. All of this was a certain death sentence before antibiotics. It is a different story now, which is the one genuinely reassuring fact in this whole mess.
How Scared Should Anyone Be?
Less than your group chat is. Pneumonic plague is the rarest form of the disease, according to the WHO. Dr. Dave Wagner, director of the Pathogen and Microbiome Institute at Northern Arizona University, told NBC the respiratory droplets travel maybe three to six feet and 'drop to the ground pretty quickly.'
Dr. William Schaffer, an infectious diseases expert at Vanderbilt University Medical Center, said close contacts are most at risk. It does not spread 'distantly across a room, but to face-to-face contacts,' he said. Morici put it bluntly: 'It's highly unlikely for most people to get the pneumonic form of the disease.'
So this is not 2020 with a rat. The people at real risk are the ones who were near her, and those are presumably the nearly 200 under observation. Panic is not the appropriate response. Paying attention is.
The Question That Actually Matters
Here is where it gets uncomfortable. Dr. Ashish Jha, the White House's former Covid response coordinator, told NBC News, 'If there were weapons programs, biological weapons programs in these labs, that would be much more concerning to me.' He added: 'We need to understand that now.'
That is the real shadow over this story. An anti-plague institute exists to study plague. It keeps plague bacteria on site. A worker at that facility dies of an unexplained respiratory illness, and the government in question reaches for the vaguest possible description. You do not need a conspiracy theory to find that suspicious. You just need to remember how Moscow has handled inconvenient health and lab questions before.
To be fair, Morici offered the sober counterpoint. 'Maybe it's going to come out that she died from something unrelated and it was just a coincidence,' she said. That is possible. Coincidences happen. But the way to rule one out is transparency, and transparency is not the Kremlin's strong suit.
The Dingo Take
'Maybe it's going to come out that she died from something unrelated and it was just a coincidence.' That is Lisa Morici's line, and she meant it honestly. She is a scientist hedging properly. Now turn it around. If it is a coincidence, Russia can prove it in about a day with a test result and a press release. The fact that we are being offered 'undetermined' instead is the part that is not coincidental.
Look, the sane reading of this story is also the boring one. Pneumonic plague is rare, it does not spread far, and antibiotics work. Nobody should be stockpiling anything. A dead 28-year-old is a tragedy first and a geopolitical puzzle second, and it is worth remembering there is a family attached to this.
But the demand Ashish Jha made is the right one. We need to understand it now, and that means independent verification, WHO access, and a straight answer about what that institute keeps in its freezers. Whether we get it depends on a government that has spent decades treating the truth as a bargaining chip. Do not hold your breath. Hold your six feet of distance, if you are into that sort of thing.
Comments