A man with dementia in Michigan got charged $42,000 for skincare products and devices, and his family only found out when his credit score cratered. That is not a freak accident at the mall. According to an NPR investigation, it is the business model. And the trail behind that business model runs through a family originally from Israel, a mall skincare industry that federal agents have been raiding for over a decade, and a recruitment pipeline for young Israelis working illegally on tourist visas.

The Free Sample Is the Bait, and You Are the Fish

You know the guy. Friendly. Young. Standing outside a mall kiosk holding a little pot of cream and complimenting your handbag like he's known you for years. Most of us keep walking. Some of us stop. More than 50 people who stopped, including shoppers, family members, and former employees, spent a year telling reporters Caley Fox Shannon and Monika Evstatieva that the ending of their stories is not a free sample.

The investigation draws on state and federal lawsuits, hundreds of online reviews, and nearly 500 consumer complaints obtained through Freedom of Information Act requests. The common thread is Mazal Group, a California company that manages dozens of skincare brands sold in thousands of stores worldwide. Every one of those brands is owned by one family, and every store in these stories has a contract to buy products from the group.

Walkers Confiscated, Zeros Added

Let's go through the cases, because the details are the whole point. In New Mexico, a woman alleges in a lawsuit that a spa employee sold her a $30,000 red-light therapy device and charged her $78,000 for what he called sales tax, without her consent. That is $78,000 in tax on a $30,000 purchase. Math is hard, apparently, unless you are the one holding the card reader.

In Hawaii, a disabled woman went to the back room of a spa for a "free" facial. She wrote in a complaint to the state that the salesperson took her walker and wouldn't let her leave for hours until she spent $2,600. Read that again. They took her walker.

At Santa Fe Spa Center by Voupre, a 67-year-old woman was held for hours until she agreed to spend $600. Her card was supposedly declined, so she handed over another. Later she saw two charges totaling $44,280. She disputed $27,000 successfully and was stuck with $17,280. New Mexico Attorney General Raúl Torrez sued the store in 2024. "We usually don't see a business that is this brazen and this out in the open," he said.

The owner, Sahar Hori, is an Israeli national who, according to court records, is also a U.S. citizen. He closed the spa and settled with the state in 2025 for $350,000 in restitution, then settled a second customer case in February 2026 for an undisclosed amount. Financial records from that case show the store's bank account paid a Mercedes-Benz lease and the rent on a Miami high-rise apartment while customers were complaining. His lawyers say he "acknowledges that some customers were unhappy" but disputes that his business intentionally deceived anyone.

The Playbook Is Eerily Consistent

Across hundreds of complaints filed with state attorneys general, the FTC, the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, and the Better Business Bureau, customers describe the same script. A young salesperson offers free samples outside the store. If you stop, they escort you inside, and in some accounts physically pull you in. Then comes the hour-plus pitch, sometimes in a back room, with salespeople who refuse to take no for an answer. The products carry no price tags, which lets the salesperson invent "special sales" and throw in "free gifts." One shopper said the salesperson added a zero at checkout, turning $1,300 into $13,000.

At checkout, shoppers say they were told to sign a tablet without being told it was a final-sale policy that could be used against them in credit card disputes. Some were signed up for a "payment plan" that was really a high-interest loan. Some were told to authorize charges their own bank had flagged as potentially fraudulent. The receipt at the bottom of the bag says "All sales final. No refunds. No exchanges." The whole thing is engineered so that every exit is already blocked before you realize you're in a room.

The bills ran from several hundred dollars to more than $100,000. In Ann Arbor, an elderly woman was "preyed upon" at Beauty Essentials and left with $5,000 in products, and employees accused her of stealing when her daughter complained. In Manhattan Beach, California, 82-year-old retired teacher Mary Ellen Eckhert, who uses a motorized wheelchair, was charged $53,500 across four cards, including $24,045 in one visit. She is still out more than $17,000. Many shoppers went to police, and arrests were almost never made.

Five people hid what happened from their families for months or years. One woman fell into a deep depression. "I just felt like if this is the way people are, I don't want to live in a world like this," she said.

The Family Behind the Brands

These stores were independently owned and thousands of miles apart, but they all sold Voupre, a brand sold exclusively by Mazal Group. Mazal is a family business, owned by Daphna Oded Weingarten and run with her husband, Eli Weingarten, her brother, Avihu Oded, and his ex-wife, Adi Sharvit Oded.

"Mazal" means "luck" or "good fortune" in Hebrew. The Weingartens and Odeds are originally from Israel, according to former staff, and so are the majority of corporate employees and licensees, meaning store owners. Five former employees spoke on condition of anonymity, fearing retaliation. They said a small cohort of non-Israelis staffs the design, engineering, and marketing departments and the warehouse.

The family started in 2005 with a line of hair straighteners and set up Mazal Group in 2015 to centralize a growing portfolio. It now holds more than 50 active trademarks for brands including Voupre, Avinichi, Introstem, Lionesse, and Orogold Cosmetics, which sell a nearly identical line of products through at least 2,000 stores, one former employee estimated. Why so many brands? "They had to keep remaking brands with different names to sell it a different way to the malls so that they could get a lease," a former employee said.

The family did not respond until the reporters sent a letter describing their findings. Their lawyer then said "Mazal Group does not own or operate any retail locations that sell cosmetic products or any other products for that matter. Nor does Mazal Group manufacture any products."

A 2010 Embassy Cable and a Decade of Raids

Federal agencies have investigated the Israeli-owned skincare industry before. (Premier Dead Sea, an Israel-based competitor once widespread in U.S. malls, makes through its subsidiary many of the red-light devices customers were pressured to buy.) In 2010, the U.S. Embassy in Tel Aviv sent the Department of Homeland Security a cable warning of fraud linked to the "Dead Sea industry," which had spread to 36 states. According to the cable, later published by WikiLeaks, recruiters in Israel targeted young people finishing mandatory military service, promising big money at American malls, and coached them to lie to consular and border officials to get tourist visas. In the States they were paid under the table, and owners skipped payroll taxes.

Agencies then went after two businesses selling the Weingarten and Oded brands. In 2013's Operation "Salty Winds," a task force surveilled stores leased to Israeli national Shai Cohen in the D.C.-Maryland-Virginia area. According to federal records, his enterprise employed about 60 unauthorized workers and brought in nearly $4 million. Cohen, two managers, and at least seven salespeople entered fraudulent marriages to stay in the country. Agents documented the "credit card overcharge scheme" too. "There's no price tag," said Matt Grimm, the Labor Department investigator who led the task force. "Whatever the salesperson on the spot thinks that they can charge for a particular thing, they're going to get." A Christmastime raid arrested a dozen young Israelis on tourist visas. Cohen was in Israel, which set off a yearslong extradition fight, and he pleaded guilty in 2023 and served 11 months.

Omer Gur, another Israeli national, owned a larger East Coast chain. "We wanted to cut the head off the snake," said FBI Special Agent Sara Shalowitz, whose team surveilled him for three years and arrested him in Raleigh as he tried to board a one-way international flight. In 2016 he pleaded guilty to a visa fraud and money-laundering conspiracy involving more than 140 unauthorized workers and over $14 million. He served 30 months, and a dozen associates pleaded guilty too.

The Recruitment Pipeline Is Still Open

The prison sentences may not have deterred anyone. Recruiters on Facebook and Instagram advertise mall kiosk jobs, called "agalot," Hebrew for "carts," promising high incomes and a life in American cities with people your own age.

In November 2025, a 20-year-old Israeli posted a YouTube video about three months at a Texas mall store selling Introstem, a family brand distributed by Mazal. "You can make $10,000 a month like it's nothing," he said, describing a company car, a furnished apartment, and 30 percent commission. He was blunt about the legal status. "It's illegal. Why is it illegal? Because you are tourists. You are on a tourist visa, and you come to work." He said immigration authorities "aren't looking for us. Immigration is looking for the Mexicans who sell drugs, less for the Israelis who contribute to their economy." A recruiter for a Lionesse store in South Carolina said they "don't help with visas," which legal experts read as a nudge toward working on a tourist visa.

Israel's 2023 admission to the U.S. Visa Waiver Program made it easier. Most Israelis can now visit for up to 90 days visa-free with a short online application, so they no longer interview with a U.S. consular official first. "It's as simple as getting on the airplane and going," Grimm said. "But, you're still not authorized to work."

The Departments of Homeland Security, Labor, and State, the IRS, and the FBI would not say whether they still investigate these stores. Israel's Ministry of Foreign Affairs did respond. "The State of Israel unequivocally opposes violations of U.S. law, including U.S. immigration law," said deputy spokesperson Ester Buzgan. "Israeli citizens seeking employment in the United States must hold a valid work visa and comply fully with the law."

The Family Says It's the Franchisees' Fault

Mazal Group and the family have publicly shifted responsibility onto individual store owners. Bad apples, in other words, in a barrel they sell to thousands of stores.

A Hawaii class action shredded that defense. Customers sued in 2022, alleging Mazal, the Weingartens and Odeds, and store owners ran a "predatory and systematically unfair and deceptive enterprise." Mazal tried to get the case thrown out by claiming to be a mere distributor that "drop ships" for a third party. It failed. Mazal's own website advertises product development, marketing, leasing, customer relations, and accounting, and former employees said it helps owners find mall space and designs store layouts and packaging. A research firm hired by the plaintiffs concluded the owners are "involved in every step of the process." Court records show Mazal requires branded stores to sell only its products, adopt a refund policy set by the group, and send customer service inquiries to its headquarters, and its agreements even set guidelines for offering samples to passersby. You cannot write the sample script and the refund rules and then act shocked about what happens at the register.

In June, weeks before a July jury trial, the parties settled. Mazal, the families, and two Hawaii licensees agreed to pay $950,000 in restitution, with Mazal and the family responsible for $650,000. After legal fees it goes to 110 class members. Mazal and the family deny wrongdoing, and the settlement releases them from future liability for those allegations.

130 Times Wholesale and a Missing Vitamin

There's a reason salespeople can invent prices on the spot. Internal order forms show suggested retail prices up to 130 times wholesale. Voupre's Cannabis Caviar Transforming Mask costs stores $23 and carries a suggested price of $3,000. The Anti-Aging Rescue Solution that lures many shoppers costs stores $19.50 and suggests $1,300. Luxury brands rarely stretch to 20 times wholesale, one skincare marketing executive said, calling the markups "highly unusual." The margin lets salespeople negotiate whatever price earns the biggest commission.

Then there is the product. Reporters sent an unopened box of the Rescue Solution, bought by a 90-year-old Ann Arbor woman who couldn't return it, to a Massachusetts lab. It found no trace of vitamin A or E. Vitamin A can degrade, but the lab's CEO said vitamin E cannot vanish entirely and called the result "surprising and definitely suspicious." If the actives were never included, he said, "that would be misbranding." What the lab did find was a peptide comparable to a sub-$10 mainstream product, and he said you "don't need to spend $1,300" to get it on your skin. It is one box of one product, and the same formula is the basis for nearly identical creams across the family's other brands. So the $1,300 cream may not even be what it says it is. At that point you're not being overcharged. You're being robbed in a nice font.

New Company, Same Family

New stores keep opening, especially in port cities and tourist destinations. Complaints haven't slowed them down, a former employee said. "They were still expanding, opening, expanding, opening, expanding, opening." Last month, Mazal Group itself terminated its California business license. Reporters visited the Chatsworth headquarters in August 2026, where the old Mazal logo, more than 10 feet high, had been replaced by a sign reading INV Brands. Innovation Brands Inc. was founded in 2024 by Daphna and Eli Weingarten, and its website promises to "build, manage, and scale exceptional personal care brands."

The Dingo Take

$78,000 in "sales tax" on a $30,000 device. That is the number to sit with, because nobody mistakes that at a register. It's the kind of figure that only exists when the person behind the counter has stopped pretending the customer is a customer and started treating them as an account to be drained.

Now look at who gets drained. A man with dementia. A woman with a walker. Older adults and people with disabilities, the shoppers least able to push back and most likely to be ignored when they report it. The system works exactly as designed, and it has been working for over a decade while the agents who once used the phrase "credit card overcharge scheme" apparently found other things to do. The raids happened. The pleas happened. The pipeline kept running anyway.

Be precise about what the Israel angle is and isn't. It is a family business with Israeli roots, a recruitment pipeline for young Israelis who are told to lie their way in on tourist visas, and a 2023 Visa Waiver change that made that pipeline easier to open. It is not a story about Israelis in general. Israel's government says it opposes breaking U.S. immigration law, former employees say non-Israelis staff the design and engineering departments, and the people whose lives were wrecked here are American shoppers. The accountability gap is American too: five agencies would not say whether anyone is still looking.

The family at the top says it's just the store owners. Sure. And the casino says it's just the slot machines. If you set the markups, write the refund policy, and collect the checks, you don't get to be a bystander. Now the parent company has terminated its California license and reopened under a new sign. Somebody with subpoena power should stop by Chatsworth and ask some questions, preferably before the next grandfather gets his credit score wrecked by a free sample.

Sources