Lindsey Graham has been dead for three weeks and Republicans are already in danger of losing the House majority trying to replace him. The race to fill his South Carolina Senate seat has turned into exactly the kind of chaotic, self-inflicted GOP disaster that makes political operatives drink before noon.
Here Lies the Problem, Buried Next to Lindsey
Graham died suddenly on July 11 at age 71. Within days, a scramble was underway to replace him. That scramble now involves a dozen Republican candidates, a Trump-endorsed candidate nobody asked for, a man who once pretended to hike the Appalachian Trail while actually visiting his Argentine girlfriend, and a structural electoral time bomb that could temporarily hand House control to Democrats.
The New York Post reports that lawyers and candidates in the race have flagged a specific and very avoidable crisis: if a sitting Republican House member wins the Senate seat and then wins the general election in November, they vacate their House seat. That triggers yet another special election. And while that special election plays out, House Republicans would be operating with one fewer vote in a chamber where they currently hold a 218-212 majority. That is not a cushion. That is a tightrope over a volcano.
"It really does play into potentially handing the gavel to Hakeem Jeffries," an advisor to one of the candidates told the Post. No one in that sentence sounds happy about it.
Trump Picks the Sister. The Sister Is Losing.
President Trump, never one to stay out of a Senate race when he can make it more complicated, endorsed Darline Graham, the late senator's sister. He said he asked her to run "for the Good of our Nation" and that there would be "nobody better to honor the legacy of her beloved brother, Lindsey." Gov. Henry McMaster had already appointed her to finish out the remainder of her brother's term, so she came into this race with a title and a famous last name.
She is still losing. According to an Emerson poll released Thursday and cited by the Post, Rep. Ralph Norman leads the August 11 Republican special primary with 22%, with Darline Graham sitting at 19%. Neither number clears the 50% threshold needed to avoid a runoff, which would push the whole process to August 25 before a November 3 general election against Democrat Annie Andrews.
One South Carolina source told the Post that Norman had been "begging" for Trump's endorsement before the president went with Graham instead. Norman apparently decided that was fine and jumped in anyway. "She can be beaten even with [a] Trump endorsement," that source said. Whether that's true is increasingly the question.
The Candidate Who Isn't a House Member (Conveniently)
Norman actually sidesteps the House majority problem because he did not seek reelection to his congressional seat after running for governor in a June primary. So if he wins the Senate race and the general, Republicans don't lose a House vote. His campaign has been leaning into this hard.
The real headache, according to the Post, is Rep. Russell Fry. If Fry wins the GOP nomination and then beats Democrat Annie Andrews in November, he would vacate his House seat and trigger a separate 2027 special election for his congressional district. That leaves Republicans short one vote for months. In a chamber with a six-seat majority, "months" is not a comfortable word.
Norman's team is not being subtle about this. "He's not going to put the House majority in jeopardy by running," his advisor told the Post. Which is a perfectly logical argument that will be completely ignored by at least half the field.
The Rest of the Field Is Exactly What You'd Expect
Rep. Nancy Mace grabbed 12% in the South Carolina governor's race and was reportedly considering a Senate run before throwing her support to Norman. Turning Point USA followed her in backing Norman. So the field has already started to consolidate a little, though "a little" is doing a lot of work in a twelve-candidate primary.
Then there is former Gov. Mark Sanford, who is, per the Post, "all the way" in. You may remember Sanford from 2009, when he told his staff he was hiking the Appalachian Trail and then disappeared for six days to Argentina to visit the woman who was not his wife. He announced last week that he wants to address the national debt. The national debt. That is his pitch in a Trump-era South Carolina Republican primary. Good luck, Mark.
Also running: businessman Mark Lynch, who lost to Lindsey Graham in the June primary and blamed voter fraud for the result. He has revived his campaign. Lt. Gov. Pamela Evette considered running but opted out after losing the governor's primary with Trump's endorsement, which tells you something about the shelf life of that particular credential in South Carolina right now.
The Timeline Is Brutal and the Margin Is Thin
Republicans pick their nominee on August 11. If nobody clears 50%, the top two candidates go to a runoff on August 25. Then the winner faces Democrat Annie Andrews in the November 3 general election. That is three elections in roughly three months to fill a seat held by one man for over two decades.
Andrews, the Democratic candidate, is not leading in any polling, and South Carolina is not a swing state. But the Post's reporting makes clear that the real danger for Republicans isn't losing to her in November. It's stumbling so badly through their own primary chaos that they hand Democrats a procedural advantage in the House they don't even have to win an election to get.
As one longtime state GOP operative put it to the Post, with admirable concision: "It's a cluster."
The Dingo Take
Lindsey Graham spent 22 years in the Senate. He was a hawk, a Trump critic who became a Trump loyalist, a bachelor who loved his cats, and a man who could work a Sunday show green room like nobody's business. Whatever you thought of him, he was a professional politician who understood the machinery of power. The race to replace him is currently being run by twelve people who, collectively, are at risk of accidentally giving Hakeem Jeffries a promotion.
This is the part where someone is supposed to say that the system is working or that democracy is messy but resilient. Skip it. What is actually happening is that a party with a six-seat House majority is fielding candidates who would shrink that majority through the act of winning. They are being warned about this explicitly, by lawyers, by operatives, by advisors on the record, and multiple candidates are running anyway. The discipline required to govern is apparently optional when there is a Senate seat up for grabs.
Trump endorsed the dead senator's sister, who is currently losing to a man who couldn't even get Trump's endorsement when he went looking for it. Mark Sanford is campaigning on deficit reduction in a MAGA primary. The timeline runs through two more elections before November. "It's a cluster" is the most accurate thing anyone has said about American politics in weeks, and it was delivered by an anonymous GOP operative talking about a Senate race in South Carolina. We are so back.
Comments