Major League Soccer just handed the keys to a former Apollo Global Management senior partner who thinks American soccer can beat baseball. That's either a visionary bet or a very expensive delusion, and the league has until 2029 to figure out which.
The Last Commissioner You'll Ever Know Is Leaving
Don Garber has been running Major League Soccer since 1999. Let that sink in. The man took over a 10-team league that was hemorrhaging money and treated as a punchline by serious sports fans, and over the next 27 years turned it into a 30-team operation with 23 soccer-specific stadiums and youth academies across the continent. That's an actual achievement, not a PR spin.
Now he's handing it off. According to NPR, MLS owners voted this week to name Los Angeles FC co-owner Larry Berg as the next commissioner, with Berg officially taking over on January 1, 2027, after a transition period. Berg becomes the first new MLS commissioner since the Clinton administration. The bar is set. The pressure is real.
So Who Is This Guy?
Berg is 60 years old, grew up in Cherry Hill, New Jersey, started playing youth soccer in 1974 when his local league had exactly two teams and they played each other every single weekend. He was, he joked at his introductory press conference Tuesday, a very dedicated fan of one specific rivalry. He was also apparently good enough to compete in a state championship against Peter Vermes, who is now the head coach of Sporting KC.
He studied economics at Wharton, did graduate work at Harvard, then spent decades at Apollo Global Management, one of the largest private equity firms on the planet. He became a senior partner. He got rich. Then he co-founded LAFC in 2014, the team debuted in 2018, and since then the club has won an MLS Cup, a U.S. Open Cup, and finished as the league's best regular-season team twice. As MLS franchises go, LAFC is genuinely well-run. Berg also served as co-chair of the league's Sporting and Competition Committee, which oversees rule changes. NPR reports that around 125 candidates were considered before owners landed on Berg. He will divest his LAFC ownership stake to take the job.
The Ambition Is Not Small
In 2020, Berg publicly predicted that soccer and MLS would eventually surpass baseball and hockey to become the third most popular sport in the United States, behind only football and basketball. He repeated that belief Tuesday. You have to respect the confidence, even when the current data suggests it's a reach.
A recent Gallup poll, cited by NPR, found that professional soccer sits in fourth place among American pro sports fans, behind football, basketball, and baseball, but ahead of hockey, tennis, and golf. So Berg isn't hallucinating. The gap to baseball is real. But predicting you'll close it is the kind of thing you say when you're trying to sell a vision to owners who need to believe the league's best days are ahead. Berg at least has the receipts from LAFC to show he's not purely blowing smoke.
His stated priority is improving the on-field product. "I would say that's my No. 1 job," he said Tuesday. More transfer revenue, better player development, stronger clubs. It's the right answer. Whether the money and the will are there to back it up is the actual question.
The Timing Is Either Perfect or Terrifying
Berg takes over at what NPR correctly describes as a pivotal moment for the league. This summer's FIFA World Cup in North America just wrapped, and MLS is hoping the wave of soccer attention translates into sustained fan interest, the way these things almost never actually do. Hope is not a strategy, but it's what the league has right now.
Next year, MLS shifts its season calendar from its traditional spring-to-fall American schedule to a summer-to-spring format, aligning with European leagues. That is a genuinely significant structural change, the kind that confuses casual fans and tests the loyalty of the ones you already have. And the current media rights deal with Apple TV expires in 2029, which means Berg's first major negotiation could define the financial ceiling of the entire league for the next decade. Labor talks are also looming. The honeymoon period, if there is one, will be short.
The Private Equity Part Is Worth Watching
Berg made a point Tuesday of arguing that his private equity background would be an asset in the commissioner role. "It's about a sense of urgency. It's about rolling up the sleeves, being in the trenches, asking good questions, aligning people toward a common goal," he told reporters.
That's a reasonable pitch. Private equity guys at their best are relentless operators who cut through institutional inertia and force decisions that bureaucracies avoid. At their worst, they extract value from the thing they're running, optimize for short-term returns, and leave a husk behind. The MLS commissioner job, historically, has required someone who can play a very long game. Garber's 27-year run is proof of that. Whether Berg's instincts run toward patient institution-building or toward hitting quarterly metrics is the question no press conference can fully answer.
The Dingo Take
You are supposed to look at a 60-year-old Apollo Global Management veteran taking over a sports league and feel reassured. And maybe you should. Berg's LAFC track record is real, his committee work shows he understands the product, and his ambition is the right kind of ambitious rather than the delusional kind. But private equity has a brand problem for a reason, and handing one of America's fastest-growing sports leagues to a guy whose career was built on leveraged buyouts is the kind of decision that deserves more scrutiny than a feel-good introductory press conference provides.
The honest truth is that MLS is at an inflection point that Garber, whatever his considerable virtues, was probably not the right person to handle. The Apple TV deal, the labor fight, the calendar change, the post-World Cup moment, all of it demanded someone with a fresh mandate and a genuine appetite for disruption. Berg at least checks those boxes on paper. Whether he's the visionary who finally makes American soccer matter the way it does everywhere else on earth, or just another rich guy who talks a great game until the hard decisions arrive, we genuinely don't know yet.
January 1, 2027 is the start date. Mark it. Because the next five years of American soccer either begin something real or confirm what the cynics have always suspected: that MLS is a nice regional product that will never quite make the leap, no matter who is running it.
Comments