The Trump administration announced Thursday that excavation will begin within two weeks on a 250-foot gilded arch to be planted between the Lincoln Memorial and Arlington National Cemetery, a project currently being challenged in active litigation. The arch — white, gold-detailed, stamped with 'ONE NATION UNDER GOD,' and topped with a winged Lady Liberty figure and spread-eagle gold eagles — is facing a lawsuit arguing it lacks the congressional authorization legally required to exist. None of that appears to be slowing anyone down.
What They're Actually Building Here
Let's be specific about what this thing looks like, because the renderings are doing a lot of work. According to The Guardian, Interior Secretary Doug Burgum posted artistic mockups of the planned structure on X, showing a towering white arch with gold detail, the words 'ONE NATION UNDER GOD' stamped across it, a winged torch-bearing golden figure on top, and gold eagles with their wings flung outward on both sides.
It is, in other words, exactly what you'd design if someone handed you a unlimited budget, a copy of Ayn Rand, and zero architectural oversight. Burgum called it 'one of the Great Pieces of American Architecture, befitting the most powerful Capital in the World.' The capitalization choices there are his own.
The arch would stand 76 meters tall and sit in what Burgum described as a 'barren traffic circle' between the Lincoln Memorial and Arlington National Cemetery. He also noted, apparently as a flex, that over 70 cities worldwide already have 'beautiful arches' but the US will soon have 'the most spectacular and beautiful arch of them all.' France, consider yourself warned.
The National Park Service Said the Quiet Part Out Loud
Here is where it gets genuinely remarkable. The Guardian reports that a National Park Service report released Friday actually backed the project — and then, in the same document, acknowledged it would cause 'adverse effects to the sightlines between a host of iconic landmarks, disrupting the historical significance of dozens of nearby sites.'
Read that again. The government's own report on the government's own project confirmed the project would damage the historical integrity of the surrounding area. And then recommended they do it anyway.
Washington's monuments are not randomly scattered. They were deliberately positioned over decades to create meaningful visual and symbolic connections between landmarks. That's not a design preference — it's the entire architectural logic of the National Mall. Dropping a 250-foot gilded vanity arch into that sightline doesn't enhance it. It bulldozes it.
There Is a Lawsuit. They Are Proceeding Anyway.
Three veterans and an architectural historian have filed suit arguing that congressional authorization is both legally necessary and entirely absent for this project. Nicolas Sansone, an attorney with Public Citizen Litigation Group representing the plaintiffs, told The Guardian that 'construction cannot and should not proceed apace' and that he's 'very confident' the courts will ultimately agree.
The Department of Justice responded Thursday by filing a document arguing the lawsuit should be thrown out. So the administration's legal strategy is essentially: move fast, dig holes, and hope the courts shrug. It is a bold approach to democratic governance.
Burgum's historical defense of the arch is that the idea of putting a monument in that circle has been 'bouncing around for more than a century,' citing old congressional discussions. What he doesn't mention is that a century of Congress repeatedly choosing not to build something is not, typically, the legal basis for building it now without asking them.
This Is One Piece of a Much Larger Redecorating Project
The arch is not a standalone impulse. The Guardian reports it is part of a broader campaign by the Trump administration to physically reshape Washington in its own image. The list includes renaming and renovating the Kennedy Center, constructing a large new White House ballroom, refurbishing the Lincoln Memorial reflecting pool, and rebuilding a golf course in East Potomac Park that would meaningfully reduce public access to running and biking paths.
The golf course detail is doing a lot of heavy lifting in that list. Reducing public green space in a major American city so a golf course can be rebuilt — while simultaneously building a monument in a public park between two of the country's most sacred memorial sites — is a coherent aesthetic vision, at minimum.
What it is a vision of is a separate question.
The Dingo Take
You are supposed to look at that rendering — the gold eagles, the winged liberty figure, the 'ONE NATION UNDER GOD' stamped across a 250-foot arch shoved between the Lincoln Memorial and a military cemetery — and think: yes, this is what the National Mall was missing. The government's own National Park Service couldn't quite get there either, given that their official report admitted adverse effects to historic sightlines before recommending the project proceed. When your own environmental review says 'this will damage the area's historical significance' and your response is 'shovel's in the ground in two weeks,' you have stopped pretending the goal is preservation.
The lawsuit is the only thing currently standing between this rendering and a hole in the ground. Three veterans and an architectural historian, represented by Public Citizen, are doing more to protect the integrity of Washington's memorial landscape than the Interior Department, the National Park Service, or the Department of Justice combined. The DOJ, for its part, is actively trying to get the case dismissed so the digging can continue unimpeded. That is where we are.
Doug Burgum cited a century of congressional discussion as justification for proceeding without congressional authorization. That argument is so circular it nearly qualifies as architecture itself. Congress talked about it and didn't do it. The lesson Burgum drew from that is: therefore we should do it, without Congress. The courts will either stop this or they won't. If they don't, in a few years there will be a gold-eagle-encrusted arch between the Lincoln Memorial and Arlington Cemetery, and every photo of the Washington skyline will require an explanation.
Comments