Texas Democratic Senate candidate James Talarico spent two weeks off the trail with the flu. Republicans responded the way mature adults always do: by demanding a hostage photo. Ken Paxton asked for 'proof of life,' a picture of Talarico holding a dated newspaper, while he himself has ignored a debate request for 85 days.
A Sick Man, a Newspaper, and a Ransom Note Energy
Here are the facts, according to NBC News. Talarico's last in-person event in Texas was September 26. On September 30, he joined a forum virtually and told people he wasn't feeling well. Then he went quiet until Friday, when he returned to the trail.
His explanation, given to NBC Dallas-Fort Worth on Sunday, was about as dramatic as a Tuesday. 'A nasty case of the flu.' He stayed in bed, drank fluids, and worked from home because his campaign apparently doesn't believe in sick days. He said he skipped events so he wouldn't get anyone else sick.
That's it. That's the scandal. A man in a competitive Senate race caught a virus and, in a shocking display of basic public health sense, stayed away from crowds.
The Internet Did What the Internet Does
Naturally, some conservatives decided the flu story wasn't spicy enough. They speculated that Talarico had stepped away for mental health reasons, which is a fine thing to speculate about if your goal is to treat mental health as a punchline and a smear at the same time.
One right-wing influencer went further and claimed, falsely, that Talarico was receiving treatment at the Lindner Center of Hope in Ohio. Not 'might be.' Was. Stated as fact, which is a remarkable level of confidence for a guy who apparently had no evidence.
The Lindner Center then publicly shut it down on Sunday, saying Talarico has never received treatment there. So a real facility had to issue a statement to correct a guy on the internet who made something up about a politician with the sniffles. Talarico's own take was more restrained than ours would have been: 'The internet's doing its thing.'
Paxton Wants a Photo, Trump Wants a Debate
Paxton, the state attorney general and Talarico's Republican opponent, called for Talarico to show 'proof of life' with a picture of himself and a newspaper showing the date. That is a phrase you use for kidnapping victims. Paxton used it for a guy with a cold.
Then Trump showed up in San Antonio on Wednesday to stump for Paxton, pointed at Talarico's absence, and urged him to debate Paxton. Read that again. Trump told Talarico to debate Paxton. At a Paxton rally. Presumably while Paxton stood there nodding.
Talarico, to his credit, took the bait and ran with it. 'I agree with President Trump,' he said Sunday. 'I think Ken Paxton should debate.'
Eighty-Five Days of Radio Silence
This is where the story turns from silly to genuinely funny. Talarico noted that Paxton hasn't responded to a debate request in 85 days. Eighty-five. That is not a scheduling conflict. That is a witness protection program.
Talarico has accepted debate invitations from multiple media outlets. Paxton hasn't accepted any. As of the reporting, no debates are scheduled. The only candidate in this race who has been missing in action on the one thing voters actually want to see is the one demanding photographic evidence that his opponent is alive.
Talarico's line is the one that will get screenshotted: 'Ken Paxton has asked for proof of life for me. I'm asking for proof of spine from him.' Okay. That's good. We'd have taken it.
Even Democrats Admit the Timing Stunk
In fairness, because we do try to be fair now and then: NBC News reports that some Democrats admitted privately that Talarico's absence was less than ideal in a tight Senate race. Disappearing for roughly two weeks in October is not a campaign strategy anyone designs on purpose.
But there's a difference between a bad stretch of the calendar and a scandal. Getting sick is not a character flaw. It happens to people who run for office, and it happens to people who don't. The only people who treated it like a mystery were the ones who needed it to be one.
The Dingo Take
Remember the old Soviet habit of announcing that a leader was 'resting' and then waiting to see who got nervous? Every rumor was a power grab waiting to happen. Paxton's allies are running the same play on a man with the flu, except the cold war is a Senate race and the missing leader is the one hiding from a debate stage.
Look at what the Texas right-wing information ecosystem produced in two weeks. A 'proof of life' demand. A fabricated claim about a specific psychiatric facility that the facility itself had to publicly deny. A president at a rally telling the other guy to debate the candidate he's rallying for. All of it aimed at a story that, in the end, was a man staying home so he wouldn't cough on strangers.
Here's the thing. Voters don't need a photo of Talarico with a newspaper. They need Paxton to show up somewhere, anywhere, and answer a question without a script. He's had 85 days. If he wants to know what proof of spine looks like, it looks like a podium, a moderator, and a man standing behind it. Until then, the only candidate in this race who appears to be hiding is the one with the nice, healthy lungs.
Comments