Donald Trump stood in front of a Wasilla crowd on Tuesday night, invited two Alaska diesel mechanics onto the stage, and signed their pardons like he was handing out door prizes at a Rotary Club raffle. The men had pleaded guilty to conspiracy to violate the Clean Air Act. The president's review of the experience: "What an honor. I love doing this stuff."
A Pardon, Live, With Applause
Fox News reports that the rally was a midterm event at the Curtis D. Menard Memorial Sports Center, and the pardons were part of the programming. Trump called up Zachary Czubak and Patrick Fleming, co-owners of an Anchorage diesel repair shop, and gave them what he called "an unconditional pardon." He also referenced an earlier pardon for Mackenzie "Mac" Spurlock, a Wasilla diesel shop owner.
The signing happened in front of supporters, on a stage, as part of a campaign event. Clemency used to be something that involved paperwork, a review process, and at least the pretense of solemnity. Now it's a segment.
Trump also found time to take a swipe at Joe Biden's autopen while signing. "Something that Joe Biden would be unable to do because he was unable to sign his signature," he said. Cute. Hold that thought, because we're coming back to it.
What These Guys Actually Admitted To
Let's be clear about what the men were pardoned for, because the rally framing was all persecution and no facts. Per the Justice Department's case, Czubak and Fleming were among three co-owners of a shop called "Arm Rippin Toys." They admitted to removing federally required emissions-control equipment and tampering with monitoring devices on at least 37 diesel vehicles between July 2019 and September 2020.
They pleaded guilty in 2022. Nobody dragged them into court on a hunch. They stood up and said, yes, we did this.
Prosecutors said the shop collected roughly $100,000 for the modifications. So this wasn't a charity operation where selfless wrenchers kept widows' trucks running through the Alaskan winter. It was a business that got paid to rip out pollution controls, and then admitted it.
The 'Persecuted Mechanics' Narrative
Trump defended the men by saying their work kept trucks running in Alaska's extreme cold and that their Biden-era prosecutions were unfair. That's the pitch, and it lands well in a sports arena full of people who like their trucks loud and their regulations quiet.
One of the pardoned men thanked the president from the stage. "It really did destroy us," he said. "It destroyed friendships. It destroyed families." That's a human cost, and nobody should pretend consequences don't ripple out. But he pleaded guilty. The consequences followed from something the shop admitted to doing, 37 times, for money.
The Fox headline machine is already calling this a "right-to-repair crackdown" that Trump is correcting. Those are very different things. Fixing your own truck is right-to-repair. Deleting the emissions system so the truck can belch what the law says it can't is a federal crime. Everyone on that stage knows the difference, and so does everyone who wrote the chyron.
The Pipeline Was the Real Headline Act
The pardons weren't even the main event. Trump used the rally to announce that an 800-mile natural gas pipeline in Alaska had secured every necessary federal permit. "Every single permit that you need, you can start tonight," he told the crowd.
Start tonight. Because that's how permitting works for an 800-mile pipeline across one of the most remote and ecologically sensitive places in North America: somebody says so on a Tuesday and the bulldozers fire up by dinner. Fox News Digital reached out to the White House for details on the project's federal permitting status, which is the kind of follow-up question that tells you something.
The pardons and the pipeline fit together, though. Both are a message to a specific audience: environmental rules are for suckers, and the president will personally make sure you don't pay for ignoring them.
Clemency as Campaign Content
A midterm rally is where you throw red meat to the base, and pardoning environmental violators on stage is a very specific cut. It tells voters that the law is a negotiable thing, that a conviction from the wrong administration doesn't count, and that the right people will always get a way out.
And Trump said the quiet part with real enthusiasm. "I love doing this stuff." Not "I believe justice demands it." Not "I reviewed the case and found a grave error." He loves it. It feels good. The crowd claps. That's the whole rationale.
The Dingo Take
Picture Joe Biden at a rally in Pennsylvania, pulling two guys up on stage who'd admitted to defeating federal worker-safety protections on 37 machines for a hundred grand, and signing their pardons while the crowd cheered. Fox would run wall-to-wall coverage for a week. The word "autopen" would be the least of the president's problems, and somebody would have a chart about the rule of law.
But it's Trump, so it's a feel-good story about persecuted mechanics. These men were not framed. They pleaded guilty. The "persecution" was prosecutors enforcing a statute that Congress wrote and that exists so Alaskans, and everyone else, can breathe. Wiping that away on a stage, between the pipeline announcement and the autopen joke, is not clemency. It's a campaign prop.
Here's the thing about "I love doing this stuff." He means it. The pardon power is one of the few pieces of the job with no checks, no committee, and no one telling him no, and he has figured out it makes great television. Expect more of it. The midterms are weeks away, and apparently every rally is a chance to free somebody.
Comments