Pennsylvania's Republican-run state senate has once again let a bipartisan bill for child sexual abuse survivors wither, after trying to bolt it to a voter ID expansion that they knew Democrats would refuse. The measure, which would open a two-year window for victims to sue their abusers, passes the state house, hits the senate, and dies. Again. It expires November 30.
The Guardian reports the bill is now on the verge of dying for good this session, which means the clock resets and survivors who have waited for years get to wait some more.
A Bill Everyone Claims to Love, Going Nowhere
Here is the basic ask. Pennsylvania would amend its constitution to open a temporary two-year window in which people abused as children can file lawsuits over assaults that happened years ago, long after the normal statute of limitations ran out. Many survivors take decades to come forward. That is not a loophole. That is how trauma works.
The proposed amendment cleared the Democratic-controlled state house in June. Then it landed in the Republican-controlled senate, where it did not get taken up. Governor Josh Shapiro noted earlier this year that the bill has passed the house six times since he took office. It has never reached his desk.
Six times. If a toddler's tantrum recurred that predictably, we would call it a pattern.
The Voter ID Hostage Situation
The reason it keeps dying has a name, and the name is voter ID. Republican senators tried to tie the survivors' amendment to a separate push to expand voter identification requirements, which they knew is a red line for many Democrats in the chamber.
Look at what that move does. It takes a bill that victims' advocates have fought over for years and makes it the price of admission for an unrelated partisan priority. You want justice for people who were raped as children? Great. First, we need you to sign off on our election agenda.
Republican leaders then turned around and tried to blame Democrats for the failure, claiming victims were being harmed by inaction on voter ID. Read that again. The hostage-takers are blaming the hostage's family for not paying the ransom.
Seven Years After the Priest Scandal
None of this started yesterday. Democrats have been pushing versions of this law since at least 2018, after a sprawling scandal in Pennsylvania's Catholic church. Investigators found more than 300 predator priests who had harmed at least 1,000 children. That is the documented number. The real one is almost certainly worse.
Then came 2021, when the delay was not only the Republicans' fault. Internal systemic failures by the administration of then governor Tom Wolf, a Democrat, kept voters from getting to decide the question in a statewide referendum. Credit where it's due: Democrats fumbled this one too, and survivors have been frustrated by politicians of every stripe more than once.
Mark Rozzi, the former Democratic state house speaker and a survivor of abuse by a Catholic priest, said he was disappointed in the senate. He also blamed Shapiro for not doing more. So no, this is not a clean morality play where one party wears a halo. But one party controls the chamber where the bill goes to die, and that party chose the voter ID gambit.
What Other States Already Learned
Pennsylvania is not breaking new ground here. Similar measures have passed in a number of states in recent years, from New York to Louisiana. The idea is hardly radical.
New York's Child Victims Act extended the statute of limitations and led to settlements including $800 million paid to more than 1,300 people who said they were sexually abused by clergy members and lay leaders of the Catholic archdiocese of New York. The state's Adult Survivors Act sparked more than 2,500 lawsuits and helped bring down the likes of Bill Cosby, Sean "Diddy" Combs and Harvey Weinstein.
That is what a lookback window does. It lets courts examine what institutions knew and when they knew it. Which, if you're an institution with something to hide, is the entire problem.
The Constitutional Catch That Makes This Worse
Pennsylvania makes this harder than it needs to be. To amend the state constitution, a measure has to pass two consecutive legislative sessions with identical language. The session ends November 30, this year's measure was never taken up by the senate, and so the whole process has to start over.
In practice, every stalled session burns two more years of a survivor's life. Some of these people are elderly. Some will die before a court ever hears them. The delay is not a bureaucratic inconvenience. It is the outcome some people are hoping for.
The Midterm Escape Hatch
Democratic state senator Maria Collett pointed to the November 3 midterms as the way out. If voters re-elect Shapiro and hand Democrats both chambers, she wrote on Facebook, "a Democratic trifecta can finally get statute of limitations reform to the governor's desk."
Polling by Politics PA suggests Democrats have a 65 percent chance to capture the state senate and a 90 percent chance to hold the house. Shapiro is a near-certainty for re-election. So the odds are decent, which is a strange thing to say about a fight over whether abuse survivors get their day in court.
The Dingo Take
You are being asked to believe that a voter ID bill and a child abuse lookback window belong in the same legislative package. They don't. Nobody drafting a serious bill would stitch them together by accident, and nobody who wanted the survivors' measure to pass would use it as a bargaining chip. The tie-in is the tactic. It gives senators a way to say they are not against survivors, they are just for election security, while the amendment quietly expires on a calendar they control.
And the Democrats do not get a free pass. The 2021 referendum was botched on Tom Wolf's watch, and Mark Rozzi is right that survivors have watched politicians of both parties promise action and deliver delay. But the difference between a stumble and a strategy matters. One party fumbled. The other pulled the bill off the field.
So here is where it lands. Voters get a say on November 3, and survivors who have waited since the priest scandal broke are now waiting on an election to do what a vote in the senate could have done for free. If you live in Pennsylvania, you know exactly what question is on your ballot, even if it does not appear in print. Who got in the way of the people who were hurt as kids? Go answer it.
Comments