Eleven people who have voted for Donald Trump over the past decade were asked how they feel about the country one week before the midterms. They said "messy," "divided," "disarray," and "scary." Only two of the eleven told NPR they're happy with his second term, which is a rough number for a man who has spent two years insisting everybody loves him.
Eleven Trump Voters Walk Into a Focus Group
NPR has been checking in with a group of swing voters in swing states as part of a long-term reporting project called Swing Shift. Every one of them has cast a ballot for Trump at some point in the past decade. Most of them did it just two years ago, in 2024.
These are not Democratic plants. These are not Never Trump columnists with a book to sell. These are the exact people the Republican Party needs to show up and do it again, and when asked to describe the country in a word or phrase, they reached for the vocabulary of a haunted house.
Their assessment of Trump's job performance roughly lines up with national polling. Most are unhappy or underwhelmed. Many cite the war in Iran and high energy prices as major concerns. Two out of eleven are happy. Two.
Gerald Is Still Here, Bless Him
Let's start with the loyalist, because every election story needs one. Gerald, a Georgia voter, gives Trump an A+++. Three pluses. He voted on the first day of early voting for Republicans Mike Collins for Senate and Rick Jackson for governor.
"Red all the way down the ballot," Gerald said. Then he added a detail that deserves its own plaque. In one race, the only name on the ballot was a Democrat running unopposed. Gerald wrote in his own name instead, "because I refuse to give a Democrat my vote."
That is commitment. That is also a man casting a vote for Gerald in a race where Gerald was not a candidate. Democracy is beautiful.
Wally Gave the President an F and Meant It
Now meet Wally, who also lives in Georgia and also voted for Trump in 2024. Every time NPR has asked him since March, he has given the president an F. "I just don't think that he's an effective leader," Wally said, "and I thought that as Americans we'd do so much better."
His top issue is inflation, and he's not exactly brimming with hope that any politician can fix it. He voted early for Democratic Sen. Jon Ossoff and gubernatorial candidate Keisha Lance Bottoms, a vote against Trump and MAGA as much as anything else.
He doesn't love Democrats either. He gives both parties in Congress an F and says he thinks lawmakers are "essentially stealing money from the American public." He wants "wholesale change." That is not a man who has found a new political home. That is a man who has locked the old one and thrown away the key.
The War That Was Supposed to Take a Few Weeks
Theresa, a Pennsylvania voter, went Biden in 2020 and Trump in 2024. She grades the president a C-, and her reason is painfully simple. "Because he said the war was only going to be a few weeks. And we knew that was not the case."
Even Lee, one of the two happy voters, couldn't get through his praise without a caveat. He gave Trump an A-, and the minus is there "because the war in Iran is taking kind of long." That's the enthusiastic review. The guy who likes Trump is docking him for the war.
The pattern is hard to miss. A promise of a quick conflict, a long conflict, high energy prices, and a base that remembers exactly what it was told.
Pennsylvania Is Flipping Its Own Ballots
In Pennsylvania, three of the four Swing Shift voters backed Trump in 2024. Now three of them plan to vote for Democratic Gov. Josh Shapiro, who is seeking re-election. Theresa put it plainly: "it is going to be with the politician that we're familiar with, which is Shapiro."
Stephen lives in Pennsylvania's 1st Congressional District, one of the most competitive House districts in the country. He's sticking with Republican Rep. Brian Fitzpatrick, who has survived a Democratic wave before. For everything else on the ballot, he said, "maybe Democratic or...maybe do a write in." At the top of the ticket, he's voting Shapiro.
Only John, from Philadelphia, voted for the Republican in the governor's race. He feels like the country is "teetering" and isn't happy with either party. His worry about a Democratic win is "a lot of investigations, a lot of impeachment talk and a lot of gridlock." Out of eleven voters, that's the Republican case: please don't make Congress argue. Inspiring stuff.
Nevada Splits and the Base Stops Being a Base
Lee in Nevada says he's gotten even more Republican since the last election, partly because he landed a new job after being out of work and his economic outlook improved. Fair enough. That's one voter whose life got better.
His fellow Nevadan Quintero, a Biden-to-Trump voter, is swinging back to the Democrats this year. Same state, same electorate, opposite directions.
That's the whole problem for Republicans in one sentence. Two years in, the Trump 2024 coalition isn't supplying reliable Republican votes. Trump hangs over every race, even though he isn't on the ballot, and the voters who put him back in the White House are now deciding what that was worth.
The Dingo Take
Imagine Joe Biden's second year. Imagine the voters who put him over the top in 2020 going on the record a week before the midterms to say the country feels "scary" and "in disarray," with only two of eleven happy and one handing out an F every time he's asked. Imagine a war that was supposed to last a few weeks still grinding on, with gas prices stuck high. Fox would have run a countdown clock. Every Republican in America would be calling it a mandate for impeachment, and they'd have the hearing schedule printed already.
But it's Trump's war, Trump's prices, and Trump's coalition, so the framing gets softer. "Challenges." A "fraying." A president who hangs over every race while insisting he isn't responsible for any of them. The standard we'd apply to anyone else is simple. You made promises, you got the job, and the people who gave it to you are telling you how it's going.
Here's what matters. These voters are not rushing into the arms of the Democratic Party. Wally gave Congress an F, both sides. John is dreading gridlock. Stephen might write somebody in. This is not love. It's a refund request. Whether Democrats can turn a protest into a vote is their problem. But the people who handed Trump a second term are the ones now describing the result, and the word they keep reaching for is "scary." Nobody had to put that in their mouths.
Comments