Minutes from the Federal Reserve's October meeting show nearly every official expects another rate hike in December, two floated doubling the usual size of it, and the central bank's own members say inflation is "headed in the wrong direction." Meanwhile, mortgage rates have topped 7%, home sales have withered, and the president is still trying to fire one of the officials who wanted to hike sooner.
Explain Like I'm 5 · 43-second video
Narrated and captioned. Made by The Dingo Daily from this article.
The Minutes Read Like a Group Chat Nobody Wanted to Be In
The minutes, released three weeks after the Oct. 27-28 meeting and first reported by the New York Post, show a committee that is no longer politely nodding along. Nearly all of the Fed's officials expect a hike in December. "Some" wanted one in October. Two of them, governor Lisa Cook and Cleveland Fed president Beth Hammack, formally dissented because they wanted higher rates immediately.
Two participants floated a half-point increase for next month, which is double the usual move. A "vast majority" of the 19 members worried that inflation could stick around even if gas prices keep falling and the effects of tariffs and the AI infrastructure buildout fade.
That last part deserves a second look. These are not people saying the current pain will pass on its own. They are saying the price pressure could outlive its causes. Wall Street already agrees, putting the odds of a December hike at nearly 95%, according to CME FedWatch.
Waller Wants a Bigger Swing and Fewer Secrets
Fed governor Christopher Waller went on CNBC Wednesday and did not bury the lede. Inflation is "headed in the wrong direction and it's spreading out" into more goods and services, he said. "If you really want to get it down, you've got to start taking more aggressive actions."
He backs a half-point hike in December, and he thinks several more might be needed, not just the two many economists forecast. His numbers are blunt. Core inflation, which strips out food and energy, has run at about a 3.5% annual rate over the past three months. The Fed's target is 2%.
Waller also pointed at a psychology problem. Businesses are increasingly willing to pass along their own rising costs, and they believe customers can swallow price increases of about 3%. "That's the kind of psychology I think we need to start breaking," he said.
Kevin Warsh Is Keeping His Cards Face Down
Here is where Waller took a shot at his own chairman. Kevin Warsh gave little guidance at his Oct. 28 news conference, and he has steadily refused to telegraph future moves, arguing that it locks the Fed into a predetermined path.
Waller's counterargument is that silence has a cost. If markets don't know whether a quarter-point hike in December will be followed by another in January, they can't price it in. If investors do see more hikes coming, they push market rates up in anticipation, and that does some of the Fed's cooling work for it.
So the chair is withholding a tool, and one of his own governors is saying so on live television. The only thing the post-meeting statement offered was an acknowledgment that "inflation remains elevated," which is the monetary policy equivalent of telling a patient he is, in fact, sick.
The Hawks Are Not Exactly Whispering
Not everyone is on the half-point train. New York Fed president John Williams, the committee's vice chair, told Axios Tuesday, "I don't think the situation calls for dramatic action." That is a real split at the top of the rate-setting committee.
But the other side is getting louder. St. Louis Fed president Alberto Musalem said in Buenos Aires that "the economy will likely require several interest rate increases before the spring of 2027." He added that the economy is expanding at a healthy pace and rates aren't yet high enough to restrain borrowing and spending. Musalem does not vote this year, but the message is clear.
San Francisco Fed president Mary Daly said she is leaning toward further hikes and worries about companies passing costs to consumers. "That's the inflationary impulse that we want to avoid," she said. Twelve of the 19 members vote on rates, though all of them join the debate, and the minutes don't say who took which side.
Your Mortgage Is the Collateral Damage
The Fed kept its key rate at 3.9% in October after raising it in September for the first time in three years. The next hike will work its way through the economy over time, pushing up borrowing costs for mortgages, auto loans and credit cards.
The housing market is already feeling it. Mortgage rates have topped 7% in recent months, and home sales have withered. Anyone hoping to buy a first home is staring at a rate that makes the monthly payment look like a ransom note.
And this is the part where the inflation fight stops being an abstraction. Higher rates are the medicine, and the people paying for the dose are the ones carrying variable-rate debt, shopping for a house, or financing a car. The Fed is not wrong that it has to act. It is also true that the bill lands on regular people first.
Trump Still Wants Cook Out
One more detail from the minutes deserves its own spotlight. Lisa Cook, one of the two formal dissenters pushing for a hike in October, is the same governor President Trump has been trying to fire. The Supreme Court ruled in June that she can keep her seat while the case is litigated.
So the White House has spent months trying to remove a Fed governor, and that governor's most recent act was voting for higher rates than the chairman delivered. Inflation is accelerating, the tariffs and oil prices the administration helped create are feeding into it, and the official the president wants gone was arguing for a faster response.
You don't have to guess what the political pressure on this institution looks like. It is sitting right there in the minutes.
The Dingo Take
In 1979, Paul Volcker took over a Fed staring at runaway inflation and decided the only honest answer was to hurt. Rates went into the stratosphere, the economy took a beating, and he got death threats for it. Nobody has to relive that, but the lesson was simple: inflation that spreads and settles into expectations is much harder to kill than inflation you catch early.
That is the fight happening inside this committee right now, and it is a serious one. Waller is right that businesses assuming they can pass along 3% price hikes is exactly the kind of habit that has to be broken. Warsh may be right that guidance can box in a central bank. Both can be wrong in different ways, and the minutes suggest they are.
What makes this ugly is the context. The administration's tariffs and energy policies are feeding the very problem the Fed is now trying to beat back with higher borrowing costs, and the same administration is trying to remove a governor for good measure. Regular people get the 7% mortgage. The people who set the table get to complain about the meal.


Comments