A jury took one look at the evidence against Hadi Matar and said yes, all of it, guilty on every count. The 28-year-old who climbed on stage at a writers' conference and stabbed Salman Rushdie 15 times was convicted Wednesday of federal terrorism charges, including engaging in an act of transnational terrorism. He's already doing 25 years for attempted murder. Now he's looking at life.
What Actually Happened on That Stage
It was August 2022. Rushdie was at the Chautauqua Institution, a western New York arts and intellectual center, about to give a talk on writers' safety. Of all topics. As he was being introduced, Matar climbed onto the stage behind him and stabbed him 15 times while the audience watched in horror.
Spectators and a fellow speaker, Henry Reese, rushed to help. Law enforcement officers on site arrested Matar after civilians physically restrained him. The whole thing happened in front of a crowd of people who had come to hear a man talk about the dangers writers face.
Rushdie survived, which he has called "a miracle." He lost sight in his right eye. His left hand and liver were badly damaged. He testified at the trial in Buffalo, telling jurors: "I can't say what his ambitions or his aim was, but the wounds were dispersed across my body." The man has a gift for understatement.
A Note to Himself: 'We Need to Kill Him ASAP'
The defense tried to argue the government had no proof of what was going on inside Matar's head. Then prosecutors showed the jury what was going on inside Matar's phone.
According to CBS News, court exhibits showed Matar repeatedly messaging contacts about the fatwa throughout 2021 and 2022. He was furious that Rushdie had survived previous threats and, in his view, emboldened others to criticize Islam. He referenced a 2006 comment by the late Hezbollah leader Hassan Nasrallah. He tracked Rushdie's public appearances. By spring 2022, he had figured out where Rushdie was scheduled to speak that August.
And in a private note to himself, prosecutors say, Matar wrote: "We need to kill him ASAP." Assistant U.S. Attorney Timothy Lynch told the jury in opening statements that Matar wanted everyone to know he was acting for Hezbollah, and framed the planned killing as jihad. The defense's "we can't know what he was thinking" argument had a tough time competing with that.
Hezbollah, a Fatwa, and a $3 Million Bounty
To understand why this happened, you have to go back 37 years. In 1989, Iran's Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ruhollah Khomeini issued a fatwa calling for Rushdie's death over his novel "The Satanic Verses," which some Muslims considered blasphemous for a dream sequence involving the Prophet Muhammad. Khomeini died that same year. The fatwa did not die with him.
Rushdie spent years in hiding under 24-hour British government protection. Iran nominally distanced itself from the edict in 1998, and Rushdie gradually returned to public life. "For two decades or more, I led a public life without a hint of trouble," he testified. But as CBS News reports, the fatwa was never formally rescinded, and Khomeini's successor Ayatollah Ali Khamenei reaffirmed it as recently as 2017. An Iranian foundation has kept a bounty on Rushdie's head worth more than $3 million.
Matar, born in the U.S. but also a Lebanese citizen, had Hezbollah photos on his bedroom walls and on his computer, prosecutors said. Hezbollah is designated a terrorist organization by the United States. The federal terrorism conviction reflects the government's position that what happened on that stage was not a lone act of violence but an operation with international ideological roots.
The Book at the Center of All of This
It is worth pausing to be clear about what "The Satanic Verses" actually is. Published in 1988, it is a novel of magical realism about two Indian actors who survive a plane explosion. Rushdie, already celebrated for winning the Booker Prize with 1981's "Midnight's Children," wrote a work of serious literary fiction. It contains a dream sequence. That dream sequence ignited one of the most prolonged, violent literary controversies in modern history.
At least 45 people were killed in riots over the book, according to CBS News. A Japanese translator was stabbed to death. An Italian translator was attacked and survived. The book's Norwegian publisher was shot and survived. Rushdie himself spent a decade effectively in hiding, protected by the British state. He has always maintained that the dream sequence was just that.
He was knighted by Queen Elizabeth II. He published a memoir about the 2022 attack in 2024, then returned to fiction with last year's "The Eleventh Hour." He tells interviews that a shadow from the attack stays with him. "Some days it's dark and some days it's not," he told 60 Minutes in 2024. He now reads on an iPad because the light and adjustable type help compensate for his lost eye. The man kept writing. That part matters.
Where Things Stand Now
Matar is already in a New York state prison serving 25 years for the attempted murder conviction. The federal conviction for transnational terrorism carries a potential life sentence. Sentencing on the federal charges has not yet been scheduled, and his attorneys had not responded to requests for comment as of Wednesday, according to CBS News.
Matar himself did not testify at the federal trial. The jury heard from Rushdie, saw the messages, reviewed the evidence, and came back with guilty on all counts. Every single charge. The defense's argument that the government couldn't prove intent apparently did not survive contact with a private note in which the defendant wrote that someone needed to be killed as soon as possible.
The Dingo Take
A man stalked a novelist for years because of a dream sequence in a book, drove to an intellectual conference with a knife, stabbed him 15 times in front of a crowd, and has now been convicted of state attempted murder and federal terrorism. He will almost certainly die in prison. And the fatwa that inspired him is still technically in effect, the bounty still posted, the ideology still out there doing its work. The conviction is justice. It is not a resolution.
There is something deeply clarifying about this case for anyone who still thinks political violence and religious extremism are abstract concerns that happen somewhere else. This happened in western New York. At a writers' conference. To a man who was about to give a talk about how dangerous it is to be a writer. The irony is so blunt it stops being irony and becomes just a fact about the world.
Rushdie kept writing. That bears repeating. He lost an eye, nearly lost his life, and published a memoir and then a novel. His attacker is going to spend the rest of his natural life in federal and state custody for an act of ideological violence that failed to accomplish its stated goal. The man with the knife lost. The man with the pen is still at his desk.
Comments