A man convicted of lying to investors about an electric truck company donated $750,000 to RFK Jr.'s MAHA political committee, nearly $2 million to a Trump-aligned committee, and then received a presidential pardon. Now four Democrats want Kennedy and EPA chief Lee Zeldin to explain what exactly they did to help, and they've given them until Oct. 20 to answer.
The Letters Nobody Has To Answer
Sens. Richard Blumenthal and Peter Welch, along with Reps. Dave Min and Mary Gay Scanlon, sent letters Tuesday to Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. and EPA Administrator Lee Zeldin. The ask is simple. Tell Congress how "influence and access have overridden the standard pardon review process," and do it by Oct. 20, as CBS News reported.
Here's the catch. Democrats are in the minority. They can write all the strongly worded letters they want, and the recipients can use them to line a birdcage. Without subpoena power, this is a polite request addressed to people with no reason to be polite back.
The real point is the calendar. If Democrats win the House or the Senate in November, those letters stop being stationery and start being the opening bid in a very long investigation.
Trevor Milton Wrote Checks, Then Got Forgiven
Let's start with the man at the center of the Kennedy letter. Trevor Milton was convicted in 2022 of lying to investors about his electric truck company, Nikola. That's fraud, plainly stated, committed against people who gave him their money.
In March 2025, Trump pardoned him. According to Federal Election Commission records, Milton and his wife had donated almost $2 million to a political committee aligned with Trump's reelection. They also gave $750,000 to the Make America Healthy Again Alliance PAC, the one aligned with Kennedy's MAHA agenda.
Milton thanked Trump for granting him "this sacred pardon of innocence." Innocence. The man was convicted by a jury of defrauding investors. He also broke the news of his pardon in an email to prosecutors that they considered cocky, which tells you everything about how a person behaves when he knows the fix was in.
Kennedy's Name Keeps Coming Up
The letter to Kennedy leans on a Reuters report from June that said he advocated for Milton's pardon to the president. A source close to Kennedy gave CBS News a different version. That person says they've heard the secretary privately say he won't advocate for any pardons.
Notice the construction. A source, anonymous, close to Kennedy, heard him say it privately. That's not a denial from Kennedy. That's a friend of Kennedy describing a vibe. HHS did not respond to CBS News, and neither did Milton.
The $750,000 sitting in a PAC built around Kennedy's signature political brand is a fact. What Kennedy said to Trump about Milton is the open question, and it's exactly the kind of question a subpoena exists to answer.
The Diesel Mechanic and the EPA Administrator
The Zeldin letter concerns a different pardon, for Troy Lake, a Colorado diesel mechanic convicted in 2024 of violating the Clean Air Act. He spent seven months in federal prison. His pardon was supported by Republican Sen. Cynthia Lummis of Wyoming and helped along by Wyoming political consultant and lobbyist Jeff Daugherty.
The Democrats cite a statement from Lake's wife that appeared to credit Zeldin with intervening to get the pardon in front of the White House. Remember who runs the EPA. The man in charge of enforcing the Clean Air Act is accused of helping a guy who broke it get out from under the conviction.
Zeldin's allies deny it. A senior EPA official, speaking anonymously, said Lake's family reached out a few times but Zeldin "did not make a recommendation or suggestion, other than just updating people internally on the facts of the case." Daugherty called it "a clean textbook pardon request" with "no special favors."
Welcome to the Pardon Economy
None of this exists in a vacuum. In September, a CBS News investigation exposed the new pardon economy, including video of lobbyists offering to "put pressure on the president" in exchange for a hefty fee from a convicted felon.
Put that sentence next to the Milton timeline. Donations flow in, a pardon flows out, and a whole class of professional fixers has materialized to sell access to the one man who can hand out forgiveness. The pardon power was written into the Constitution as a check on injustice. It has been repurposed as a subscription tier.
Rep. Jamie Raskin, the top Democrat on House Judiciary, said last month that lawmakers are gearing up to investigate "everybody along the assembly line of clemency for cash." Blumenthal runs the Permanent Subcommittee on Investigations, which has broad authority to probe corruption in government. They're building the machinery now.
The Dingo Take
The people getting robbed in the Milton story are the investors. Regular folks handed money to a guy who lied about whether his trucks worked, a jury said so, and a president wiped it away after the guy's family wrote seven-figure checks. Nobody in this pardon assembly line is calling those investors. Nobody asked what they think about the word "innocence."
Now, to be fair, the Kennedy and Zeldin allegations are contested, and the denials are on the record. The letters are questions, not verdicts. But the money isn't contested. The pardons aren't contested. The lobbyists on video offering to lean on the president for a fee aren't contested. You don't need a smoking gun when the whole building is on fire.
So here's the real story. Four Democrats sent letters that Kennedy and Zeldin can ignore on Oct. 21 with zero consequences. In January, that might not be true. Vote like it matters, because for the first time in a while, the paper trail is about to get a subpoena.
Comments