Somewhere out there is a company whose entire job is helping other companies test which shade of blue makes you click a button more. Hackers broke into that company's platform and, through it, planted card-stealing, cookie-grabbing, crypto-swapping malware on at least 178 major organizations, including the BBC, CNN, Zoom, HSBC, Salesforce and, because the universe has a sense of humor, Equifax.

Explain Like I'm 5 · 40-second video

Preview of the Explain Like I'm 5 video for this story

Narrated and captioned. Made by The Dingo Daily from this article.

One Vendor, 178 Victims

Security researcher Scott Helme, founder of Report URI, told Newsweek that his team found at least 188 infected Optimizely projects spread across 178 organizations. The list of affected sites also includes IKEA, Fox News, Alaska Airlines and GitLab. Researchers at Report URI identified the attack on Monday.

Here's how it worked. Optimizely sells software that lets businesses run experiments on their websites, showing different versions to different visitors to see what performs better. Hackers exploited a vulnerability in that Experimentation platform and injected malicious JavaScript into scripts hosted by the company. Every customer loading those scripts then served the hackers' code straight into their visitors' browsers.

None of those 178 organizations had to do anything wrong for this to land on their sites. That's the whole trick.

What the Malicious Code Could Actually Do

The list of capabilities reads like a shopping list for a very motivated criminal. According to Helme, the code could steal payment-card details, swap cryptocurrency wallet addresses so your money lands in someone else's account, capture cookies and screenshots, and redirect older iPhones and iPads to an exploit kit.

The cookie theft deserves a second look. A stolen session cookie can let an attacker hijack your logged-in session and walk into your account without ever needing your password. Peter Lowe, threat research lead at ZeroFox, pointed out that card numbers typed into a site's own forms rather than a hosted payment frame were also exposed, along with whatever the iOS exploit chains managed to grab from anyone on an unpatched iPhone.

That last one is a particularly nasty little bonus. Visit CNN on an old iPad and you might walk away with more than the news.

The Numbers, and the Fine Print on the Numbers

Helme estimates the malicious code may have been served during roughly 34 million page visits, with a possible range of 6 million to 150 million. That range is wide enough to park a cargo ship in, but he was careful to add a caveat: "That counts visits that loaded the code, not people who lost money or data. The actual harm is far smaller."

Researchers could see about $7,000 in cryptocurrency reach wallets linked to the attacker. What they could not determine is how many card numbers were stolen, and nobody outside the attackers can measure the cookie and iPhone damage. As Lowe put it, "Money is only the part we can count."

John Walsh, Field CTO at IGEL, made the distinction that matters here. Potential exposure, execution of malicious code and confirmed compromise are three different things. The 178 organizations represent potentially affected websites, not 178 confirmed corporate breaches. We don't yet know how many people actually got robbed. We just know the door was wide open.

Damage Control Has Begun

Optimizely said in a status update Tuesday that "an unauthorized party exploited a vulnerability" in its Experimentation platform, and that it has fixed the vulnerability and removed the injected code from affected projects.

Salesforce disabled Optimizely scripts across its preview and production instances as a precaution while it investigates what it called unauthorized modifications that "could load malicious code in visitors' browsers." IKEA said it is investigating to understand any potential impact on its customers.

Equifax said it immediately investigated and ceased its use of Optimizely, adding that it has not identified evidence of any compromise to its systems or data. Take that for what it is. A company that has to say that sentence out loud, in this particular industry, with this particular history, is going to get a few raised eyebrows.

The Part Where Somebody Says "AI"

Naturally, someone floated the A-word. Lowe said there's been a lot of discussion lately about offensive AI frameworks and he wouldn't be surprised to find this was an example attack. Helme, the person actually in the weeds, said researchers saw "no evidence of AI involvement."

That's worth holding onto. Speculation is cheap, and every new breach is going to get the robot-apocalypse treatment from somebody. The evidence on the table points to something much older and dumber: a trusted vendor with a vulnerability, and customers who treat third-party code like it's a load-bearing wall they never have to inspect.

The Dingo Take

Your security is only as good as your sloppiest vendor's. That's the lesson, and it's been the lesson for years, and apparently nobody at CNN or HSBC got the memo.

Think about what happened. The BBC, Zoom, HSBC and Equifax, organizations that employ armies of security people and spend fortunes on compliance audits, all handed the keys to their visitors' browsers to a third party that sells website experiments. Their own code was fine. Their own infrastructure was fine. They still ended up serving malware to what could be tens of millions of page visits, because nobody thought hard about the script they were loading from somebody else's server. That's not a hack in the usual sense. That's a trust fall into an empty room.

And before anyone relaxes because the confirmed haul is only about $7,000 in crypto: we don't know what we don't know. Nobody can see the card numbers, the hijacked sessions or the iPhones that got owned. The damage that's countable is small. The damage that isn't countable is the part keeping security researchers up at night. If your site loads someone else's JavaScript, and it does, you are one vendor vulnerability away from being the next headline. Start auditing what you let run on your pages, or enjoy explaining it to your customers later.

Sources