Thousands of flights were cancelled and the nation's airspace was shut down over the weekend, and the man in charge of homeland security spent Saturday at a college football game. Markwayne Mullin told a congressional hearing he went because he wanted to be a good uncle, and that staying home would have signaled "distrust that we're not even willing to fly."
Explain Like I'm 5 · 48-second video
Narrated and captioned. Made by The Dingo Daily from this article.
The Great Uncle Defense
Here's the setup. The FAA ordered a nationwide grounding over the weekend. Airspace closed. Thousands of flights were scrubbed. Ordinary Americans were stuck in terminals, on couches, and in rental car lines the length of a Dostoevsky novel.
And Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin, according to The Guardian's coverage of Wednesday's hearing, boarded a government plane to watch LSU play Texas. When Democratic Congressman Bennie Thompson, the committee's top Democrat, asked about it, Mullin said he'd brought his family and his great nieces, that the game had been scheduled for weeks, and that he wanted to be a good uncle.
A good uncle. The man responsible for the security of the entire country was doing uncle things. Noted.
Skipping the Game Would Have Caused Confusion
This is where the explanation goes from awkward to genuinely creative. Mullin argued that if he hadn't gone, it could have created "confusion," partly because he was due to meet Louisiana Governor Jeff Landry.
Ah, the confusion. Picture it. A cabinet secretary doesn't show up to a football game and suddenly the republic wobbles. Somewhere a governor stands at a tailgate, checking his watch, unsure what the absence means for federal-state relations.
Mullin also said his no-show might have signaled "distrust that we're not even willing to fly." So the trip wasn't a perk. It was a public confidence measure. He wasn't going to a football game. He was going to a football game as a form of national reassurance.
The Timeline He Wants You to Notice
Mullin leaned hard on the clock. "We had discussions at 10 o'clock Saturday morning. Should we cancel it? We had deep conversations about it," he told the hearing. His point was that the skies were open. "On Saturday alone, 36,000 planes flew and flew safely. Before I took off, the airspace had been open for almost 24 hours."
Okay. Maybe. If the airspace was reopened and 36,000 flights went up safely, then the safety argument is at least not absurd on its face. That's the strongest part of his case, and it deserves to be stated plainly.
But notice what the argument skips. Nobody has to prove a plane was safe to ask why the person running Homeland Security spent a weekend defined by a national aviation crisis at a college football game. Those are different questions, and he's only answering one of them.
He Paid for It. Sort Of.
Mullin said he paid for the trip himself because it was non-official business. He also said he's required to use the government aircraft for security reasons. Both of those can be true at once, and the hearing coverage doesn't detail how the two squared up in practice.
So the personal expense is covered, but the plane is the government's, because the secretary has to be protected. Fine. That's how security details work. It's also how a lot of people end up taking a very nice ride to a very nice game and calling it a logistics necessity.
We're not going to pretend we know the books here. The reporting doesn't say what he paid or how it was calculated. What we do know is the optics of a cabinet official flying private while ordinary travelers were stranded is the kind of thing that writes its own attack ad.
The Hypocrisy Counterpunch
Then came the pivot. Mullin scolded Democrats for the line of questioning. "The hypocrisy from you and from the members that want to make a big deal out of it … you guys would have done the same thing, but you would have called it a campaign event," he said.
That's a spicy deflection, and parts of it land. Politicians of every party have a long, proud history of mixing official travel with events that look suspiciously like fun. Nobody's hands are clean in the aircraft department.
But "you'd do it too" is not a defense. It's an admission with a smirk. If the answer to "why did you do this" is "someone else would have," you've basically told the committee they were right to ask.
The Dingo Take
A cabinet secretary attended a football game during a national aviation shutdown and described it as a trust-building exercise for the traveling public. That is the sentence. We did not make it better or worse. It just sits there, being what it is.
The defense had three parts: family obligation, diplomatic necessity, and civic reassurance. Any one of them is fine on its own. Stacked together, they sound like someone assembling a legal brief for a parking ticket. When your explanation needs a governor, your great nieces, and the confidence of the American flying public to hold it up, the explanation is doing a lot of heavy lifting for a trip to Baton Rouge.
Here's what actually bothers us. The airspace may well have been safe, and the 36,000 flights that went up Saturday suggest it was. Mullin might have a perfectly boring reason for being where he was. But the man runs the department whose entire job is making Americans feel looked after, and he spent the weekend teaching the country that the people in charge of the emergency get to go to the game. That's not a security failure. It's a vibes failure. And in this administration, vibes are the only thing anyone seems to be guarding.





Comments